Writing With Abandon

Reflections and ramblings about life as an educator, writer, reader, knitter, and over-thinker. Trying to do the writing only I can do.

Earth School

This week, I finished reading All the Way to the River, Liz Gilbert’s new memoir about love, grief, and addiction.

Back in the spring, when I’d seen that she was coming to the Arsht Center for a “conversation,” I booked three tickets for Ana, Kim, and I to see her speak. Our tickets included a brief meet and greet as well as a signed copy of the book. I made a calendar event for the evening, November 3rd, and then promptly forgot about it until October or so.

I wasn’t planning on reading the memoir ahead of the event, since we were going to receive a copy anyway, but Ana forgot that she’d pre-ordered it and read it, and then I figured I could at least listen to some of the audiobook with my Spotify premium membership. So I started it on my daily dog walks, but got a bit turned off by the music, and distracted by Phoebe, and ultimately decided to just wait until the event. I let some critics get in my head too, so headed into the night a bit skeptical, which, combined with work stress, didn’t make me the most receptive audience member.

The conversation was supposed to begin at 7:30pm, but for the meet and greet, we were required to get there by 5:45pm at the latest, the email said. So we did, and lined up, and I ranted to two of my closest friends as we waited in line to meet Liz.

When it was our turn, I hoped she would sign my copy of Big Magic (my favorite book of hers), but it wasn’t a signing kind of thing.

“Have we met?” she asked me when we hugged.

I told her we hadn’t.

Me, Liz, and Kim

They snapped our photo, and then we went to wait in the lobby for another hour or so before the event began.

And once it began? Whoa.

Liz is a public speaker like few I’ve ever seen. She absolutely knows how to tell a story and engage her audience, all while remaining one hundred percent authentic.

It truly was like a conversation with her. The meet and greet was just a photo op, but this? This was an intimate conversation. There weren’t that many of us.

Liz spoke about creativity and love and the process of writing this memoir. She spoke about getting to a point in your life where your past lives and loves are just a distant memory. She made us laugh, she made us tear up, and she made me nudge Ana for a stack of post-its I knew she’d have and Kim for a pen so I could take some notes.

Some small nuggets of gold I was able to jot down (some from Liz, and some that Liz quoted from others — these are not necessarily exact words, but include some exact words!):

  • We have one planet, but 8 billion worlds. Art is: take me into your world.
  • In all art, you’re revealing yourself — you’re exposing yourself, but you’re on a nude beach! What a critic is is someone who goes to the nude beach, fully clothed a with a telephoto lens, and scrutinizes you, then decides what it is. They say, I’ll tell you what she looks like naked, without taking off a stitch of their own clothing! “Get off the beach!”
  • You only need to know what you think of your art. Criticism and flattery go down the same drain — both are destabilizing. (Credited to Georgia O’Keefe)
  • The universe hates secrets.
  • Rayya would always say, since the truth is where we’re gonna end up anyway, why don’t we just start there?
  • Grief is a bill that you have to pay eventually. You can pay it all at once or in installments, but you have to pay it.
  • Be vulnerable enough to do your learning in public.

We left the evening absolutely inspired, and also exhausted from Daylight Savings Time.

As soon as I finished my next book, I launched back into Liz’s new memoir, this time with the hard, signed copy. I started from the beginning. I finished it this past Sunday, a gorgeous day, sitting on my balcony with Phoebe at my feet.

Something that has really been sitting with me is her notion that “Earth is nothing but a school for souls” (48). Liz writes:

In my life, I have certainly found that the Earth School model is a useful thought exercise during times of darkness, pain, and betrayal—for it takes me out of a victim mentality and offers up a worldview that feels far more empowering and fascinating than the limiting, anguishing cry of “Why me?!”

A more fruitful question than “Why me?” could be “How might this terrible situation be perfectly designed to help me to evolve?”

Because what if that’s really what it’s all about?

And what if we are all here to help each other evolve? (49)

I’ve found this incredibly useful lately. So I leave it here with you.

What is a terrible situation that was perfectly designed to help you evolve? And maybe, if you’re going through one now, you can reframe your “why me?” thoughts à la Liz.

Comments

17 responses to “Earth School”

  1. Fran McCrackin Avatar

    I really appreciate how you open honestly with your annoyance and some skepticism, and share how you were wowed. It shows in how you are now and forever on a first name basis with Liz! I chuckled at your friend who will always have post-its available. And Im glad she did because I really benefitted from the notes you shared here. I think my favorites are – art is take me into your world, and do your learning in public. Which we are, here.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Amy Crehore Avatar

      Those two are my favorites as well! And they definitely pushed me to show up and slice today.

      Like

  2. Joanne Toft Avatar

    Thanks for this post. I have been hesitant to get into this new book of hers. I seem to have a love/ dislike relationship with her and her writing. I love this line – perfect “What is a terrible situation that was perfectly designed to help you evolve? ” see this is when I say yep I need to read this new book. So glad you went to hear her.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Amy Crehore Avatar

      I have the same kind of relationship with her! What I will say is, I wasn’t a big fan of Eat Pray Love (didn’t like the writing either), but I really enjoyed Big Magic. I haven’t read any of her other stuff. This one was worth it, and a fast read considering the size. I hope that you enjoy it!

      Like

      1. Joanne Toft Avatar

        I really like The Signature of All Things – it is a fiction piece and I really liked it. You might check it out.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Amy Crehore Avatar

        I will! Thanks for the rec 🙂

        Like

  3. Trish Avatar
    Trish

    I think Gilbert is brave, and I am so very glad that evening that you candidly revealed was not one you were 100% anticipating also revealed her magic. I love her fiction and will give her memoir a shot. The Signature of All Things is on my top-ten list. Her historical fiction rings true every time. Thanks for the notes you shared; I had a terrific time “seeing” those fully-dressed photographers on the nude beach with their ogling. Your writing allows us an evening with her, too.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Amy Crehore Avatar

      I’m so glad you appreciated the notes! Another slicer recommended the same book — I’m adding it to my list!

      Like

  4. Sharon Roy Avatar
    Sharon Roy

    Amy,

    Thanks for bringing us along to the talk. I’ve never read any of her work. Have heard some criticism of it which makes the quote about critics as fully clothed gawkers on the nude beach apt.

    Love this note:

    We have one planet, but 8 billion worlds. Art is: take me into your world.

    and this one:

    You only need to know what you think of your art. Criticism and flattery go down the same drain — both are destabilizing. (Credited to Georgia O’Keefe)

    I love hearing writers talk about their work, so thank you so much for sharing.

    I had the good fortune to see Billy Collins read and speak last week. Maybe I should look over my notes and rustle up a post.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Amy Crehore Avatar

      I’d love to read that post! I’m a huge fan of hearing writers talk/reading what writers write about their work.

      And YES — the criticism just feels like an easy thing to do, for the sake of doing so, and after hearing her speak on it, I was then thinking, yes! Who are THEY to critique anyone? Especially if they’re not showing up as their vulnerable selves?

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Sharon Roy Avatar
        Sharon Roy

        Thanks for the encouragement, Amy. Maybe that will be next week’s slice.

        I like this Brené Brown quote:

        “At the end of the day, at the end of the week, at the end of my life, I want to say that l
        contributed more than
        I criticized.”

        Much easier to criticize than show up and be vulnerable. I try and remember that—both when I am in a critical mode and when I’m criticized or see others being criticized without nuance.

        Liked by 1 person

      2. Amy Crehore Avatar

        Another incredible writer. That quote is fantastic. Thank you for sharing!

        Like

  5. mbhmaine Avatar

    Thanks so much for sharing your experience. I really appreciate how honest you are about being skeptical and ending up wowed. The quotes you shared are definitely thought-provoking. I’m not sure I’m racing off to read her newest book, but from the comments, I think I need to read The Signature of All Things!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. margaretsmn Avatar
    margaretsmn

    How exciting to meet Liz Gilbert in person! Great photo! I haven’t read her new book yet, but I’ve enjoyed hearing some podcast interviews about it. Thanks for sharing this experience.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Amy Crehore Avatar

      It was very cool. I definitely recommend taking the chance to see any author speak!

      Like

  7. Billy Collins’ Canine Wisdom – Pedaling Poet Avatar

    […] Amy, a member of Two Writing Teachers’ Slice of Life writing community, wrote a great post, Earth School, with her notes and reflections from seeing Elizabeth Gilbert speak. We chatted in the comments. I […]

    Like

  8. Ana Valentina Patton Avatar

    An evening I’ll never forget, and how glad I am that we were together! The honesty is your writing is gold ❤
    Also, know I always carry post-its and pens for you to capture wisdom for the both of us!
    I love you, writing partner.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to Billy Collins’ Canine Wisdom – Pedaling Poet Cancel reply